Sunday, April 22, 2007

Race

This is a picture of my maternal grandfather in his WW I uniform. His eyes were the color of water. He was a first generation American; his parents were born in Sweden, and left that country poor and hungry at the turn of the century. They came through Ellis Island with thousands of other Swedes with the last name Swanson. I tried to locate them in the Ellis Island registry but gave up when, after an hour, I was only on first names beginning with "A."

When I was in law school I spent an evening riding in a patrol car with a City of Seattle police officer as extra credit for Criminal Procedure. The officer was Asian, and offered that it bothered him when people asked him where his family is "from." He explained that his ancestors were Chinese, but came to America in the early 1800's to build the railroads. The officer was born in the U.S., as had been five or six generations before him. No one has ever asked me where my family is "from."

The adoption agency we're using requires that families adopting a child of another race - in our case, Chinese - consider the child's feelings when others ask about the child's ancestry and when the child is old enough to inquire about it. We had to attend workshops and read materials about how a black or Asian child may likely feel growing up with people who don't look anything like the rest of the family. The agency required us to sign a statement to the effect that we promise to expose our Chinese daughter to her heritage, and the statement required us to enumerate exactly what resources in our community we might help us with this. Fortunately, Seattle has a huge Chinese population and there are many ways to celebrate Chinese holidays, to take classes in Mandarin, and to participate in the arts so that our daughter will know what her culture is like.

There are no guarantees, however, that she'll be interested in her culture. The agency related a story about one family who adopted a boy from Korea. They dutifully enrolled the little boy in all things Korean: marital arts, language, cooking, etc. The adopted child could not care less about the Korean culture, yet their biological child became obsessed with anything Korean. We don't intend to make our home a Mandarin home. We will wait until our adopted daughter expresses an interest in her culture before we become immersed in it. What we wish for her, fundamentally, is that she knows she is loved, and that she is an American.

10 comments:

egan said...

Huh, I'm torn on this one. At any rate, thanks for sharing Leezer.

Lisa said...

Egan:
Torn about exposing them to Chinese stuff or not enough Chinese stuff? Expliquer en français si vous êtes embarassed s'il vous plaît.

Anonymous said...

I have several close friends who are adopted. In the highschool/early college years they all had a strong desire to know where they came from. One was adopted from Korea and will probably never be able to find out anything about her roots. I guess what I'm trying to suggest is find out any information you can about exactly where she is from if she has siblings etc now before that information is lost forever.

Lisa said...

Anonymous:

Thanks for your comments. I should have added some important information in the body of my post: every adoptive parent is STRONGLY encouraged to create a "Life Book" for the child. This is basically a scrap book of every bit of evidence about the child's origins that we can find - where she came from, her medical records, the orphanage she lived in, her caregivers, etc. We have already started Song Song's book. When we travel to China to get her we will also document every step of the process for her. This will hopefully help her understand where she came from. And we WILL expose her to Chinese culture. What I meant to say was that we would like her to feel priviledged to be an American, which is how we feel. But we do want her to know where she's from and have an understanding of that as well. I just don't know if we'll go so far as to become fluent in Mandarine.

Thanks for reminding me of this point. Please sign in again, o.k.????

Anonymous said...

This was informative because sometimes I think about adopting a child from another culture. It won't be for a while but someday.

Anonymous said...

Moparmama here:
Thanks for including my Dad into your blog. As I remember my his eyes, they were a stern Paul Newman blue.
In my grandparents' generation immigrants wanted to become Americanized as quickly as possible, and did not regard their heritage as important.
So much was lost. Although Dad did not speak English until he went to school, he could not remember Swedish as an adult. All I learned in Swedish was a little song about a horse named Blanch.
I am glad that Song Song will have an opportunity to explore and respect her heritage. Her choices will influence her self identity as she learns and grows. With Georgia as a big sister, funny little Ernie and Holly as pets, and the loving attention of her parents, she will have the best of all worlds.
I can hardly wait until she becomes a member of your family. Grandpa Swanson would be very proud.
Mom

Christina said...

Friends of my in-laws adopted a little girl from China about 10 years ago. Every year we all head into Center City for the Chinese New Year celebration, which features her dance recital. The whole experience is so much fun for everyone and I think it's helped our friends' daughter to understand that different isn't bad, and that we all love everything about her.

Lisa said...

Naynay:
It's an interesting experience. It has had its highs and lows.

Lisa said...

Hi Mom:

Yes I remember Blanche the horse. The song was much more interesting when he sang it in Swedish. You're right about that generation wanting to be Americanized. I think Dad said his Mom wasn't allowed to speak German at home after she started school.

Thanks for your nice comments, Mom!

Lisa said...

Christina:
Yes, I think every child needst to know where they came from. I hope to be able to give our daughter as much exposure as she wants, whatever that is for her.